Plans for the Greenway: Markets by Memorials?

In the last week, two different groups have offered up, shall we say, contrasting visions for the Rose Kennedy Greenway. One, the Armenian Heritage Park at the intersection of Atlantic and Cross Street, is almost complete, according to the North End Waterfront. Meanwhile, a block away, the Massachusetts Department of Transportation is considering four different proposals for Parcel 9, the odd triangular strip along Blackstone Street. As the Boston Globe puts it, there are “two [proposals] for commercial and residential buildings; one for a hotel; and one for the Boston Museum, the long-planned gateway to historical Boston and New England.”

Let’s consider the juxtaposition. The Armenian Heritage Park—which, as the supporters are careful to point out on their web site, “is being constructed at no expense to the taxpayer,” has two parts:

- “The Labyrinth, a circular winding path paved in granite set in stone, celebrates life’s journey.”

Armenian Heritage Park Labyrinth

Armenian Heritage Park Labyrinth

Armenian Heritage Park (www.armenianheritagepark.org)

– “The Abstract Sculpture, a split dodecahedron mounted above a reflecting pool, commemorates the immigrant experience… The Sculpture is dedicated to lives lost during the Armenian Genocide of 1915-1923 and all genocides that have followed.”

 

Sculpture  (ArmenianHeritagePark.org)

Sculpture (www.armenianheritagepark.org)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Got that? Immigrant heritage, life, memorial to genocide, fountain, directly across the street from Faneuil Hall and the Greenway Carousel.  The block next door is a “ramp parcel” where cars escape or descend into the depths of Route 93, with a parking lot on one side of the Greenway and a parking garage on the other (you weren’t thinking of actually walking in Boston, were you?)

Then, we come to Parcel 9. where we could have commercial and residential buildings, a hotel, or a museum that would explain the “city’s ever-changing religious foundations, its intellectual leadership, its immigrant traditions, and its storied politics,” as the Globe put it. Let’s take a look at the fantastically varied, strikingly original plans proposed for the site!

 

Blackstone Market mixed use commercial/ residential (MassDOT)

Blackstone Market mixed use commercial/ residential (MassDOT)

Look, a two-story building with roof gardens. And a giant glowing red cow. I guess there wasn’t enough room for a Citgo sign.

Normandy Partners Hotel proposal (Mass DOT)

Normandy Partners Hotel proposal (Mass DOT)

Look! It’s a box, with another box on top of it! And more trees on a roof.

Normandy Partners Hotel proposal (Mass DOT)

Normandy Partners Hotel proposal (Mass DOT)

A large box with a shorter box next to it. The trees are on the ground this time.

Boston Museum

Boston Museum (Boston Museum/ Mass DOT)

… and a glass box with trees on top, with colored walls to give it a vague resemblance to an Ikea showroom.

Look, Parcel 9 is public land, no matter how long and skinny and awkward (and profitable) it might be. In past, Boston has decided that the area around Faneuil Hall is an appropriate place for memorials: in addition to the Armenian Heritage Park, the New England Holocaust Memorial is just a block from Parcel 9 at the corner of Congress and Hanover streets.

None of the various proposals are going to change the cityscape around Parcel 9 much; they’re all low and brown and boxy (except for the Boston Museum, which would be glassy and boxy). Some of them would be a lot more profitable than others, I’m sure.

But out of the four proposals, only the Boston Museum continues a major Rose Kennedy Greenway theme: celebrating Boston’s heritage and honoring the people who have been here since all of our revolutionary hullaballoo. The Greenway’s North End “Leaning Rail Timeline” and the immigrants’ quotes at Rowes Wharf are particularly interesting; find out more about them here.

Remember, Parcel 9 is part of our front yard; it’s what Boston shows the world (and a very large percentage of the world seems to visit Faneuil Hall in the summer.) We have the Freedom Trail, and Faneuil Hall’s mall with occasional colonial accents, but we don’t have institution that tells visitors about what’s happened Boston since 1800. A lot has changed in the past 212 years.

We’re talking about developing public land alongside one of Boston’s most visited tourist attractions and most visible parks, near memorials to millions of people who were murdered and starved because of their heritage. A Boston Museum would honor the heritage of all Bostonians; a glowing red cow won’t.

The Armenian Heritage Park will be dedicated on Tuesday, May 22, at 11 am. It will be beautiful.